A few years ago, this short piece by former Vancouver councillor Gordon Price made a big impression on me.
The Canadian Institute of Planners had decided to celebrate Vancouver's West End neighbourhood by giving it their 2015 “Great Neighbourhood” award. Price noted that this is ironic given that during its most recent development boom, the modern West End was widely regarded as a terrible planning decision:
…this neighbourhood of old converted single-family homes was largely bulldozed to create the Great Neighbourhood of today. The West End, during the boom era of highrise construction in the 1960s, was considered a concrete jungle – what most Vancouverites didn’t want anywhere near them: everyone’s best bad example of urban redevelopment.
Impossible to do that today. Imagine taking a square mile anywhere south of 16th Avenue and rezoning it for the kind of development that characterizes the West End.
This really surprised me as someone who moved to Vancouver in the 2000s. Nearly everyone loves the West End now! It's got a lot of relatively affordable rental apartments, it's close to all kinds of natural amenities, and it's a short walk from downtown.
Fast-forward to late 2017, and I'm digging through old newspapers at the VPL for Abundant Housing Vancouver. When I get to the 1960s, I find out that Price is right: many people really hated the modern West End when it was being built. Here are just some of the articles I found.
Quality in the West End
June 24 1965
With the greedy onrush of speculators crowding boxy apartment block next to dumpy apartment block – each new one shutting out the coveted view from another – the city has reason to be ashamed of its lack of supervision in a site so fortunate.
Quick freeze for West End skyline
Vancouver Sun, Nov. 2, 1972
Most of those council members who are not seeking re-election have been in office throughout the building-boom years, in which the West End was allowed to reach a density unparalleled in this country, perhaps anywhere this side of Calcutta. At last the first steps have been taken to control the planning nightmare which resulted.
Fairview Slopes rezoning
Fairview Slopes underwent a major rezoning in the early 1970s. During the planning process, negative comparisons to the West End were very common. Common concerns: too dense, not suitable for families, and too expensive.
Another West End Not Wanted
Concern that redevelopment on the south shore of False Creek could create another West End was expressed by several members of city council at a meeting Tuesday. Councillors called the West End “too densely populated” without enough “accommodation for families.”
Fairview for families – Bird
Nov 25 1970
Untitled column about Fairview
Vancouver Sun, Feb 13 1971
Students face ‘push-out’
Vancouver Sun, May 27 1971
AMS president Steve Garrod said the area would get the bad social environment of the West End if the rezoning goes into effect. “It will be a place of fairly expensive high-rises where students won’t be able to live,” he said.
You know the small handful of West End-like concrete apartment buildings in Kitsilano? Shortly after they went up, Kitsilano residents mobilized to stop others from being built.
Row sparks new look at zoning
Vancouver Sun, Feb 16 1972
Vancouver Sun, Feb 16 1972
High-rise plan protested
Vancouver Sun, Feb 17 1972
Vancouver Tenants Council secretary Bruce Yorke said assurances by mayor Tom Campbell “cannot be considered a sufficient guarantee that the Kitsilano area won’t in the future become like the West End.”
Plan to limit building height in Kitsilano to be drafted
Project halted in Kitsilano
Vancouver Sun, Mar 13 1972
Highrise limit backed at Kitsilano meeting
Vancouver Sun, Apr 13 1972
High-rise plans opposed
Vancouver Sun, Mar 15 1973
‘Threat to Kitsilano’ High-rise plan protested
Vancouver Sun, Aug 17, 1973
The West End really was dramatically transformed during the 1960s and 1970s, as can be seen in a casual glance at this map. With the benefit of hindsight, most contemporary objections to this seem wrong or at least short-sighted. To this day the West End provides a significant amount of Vancouver's purpose-built rental units, and half of the West End's population lives in buildings constructed 1960-1980.
Perhaps we should take a longer view when evaluating objections to densification and new apartment buildings. Wouldn't Vancouver be nice with a few more West Ends?
All articles were found on microfiche at the Central Vancouver Public Library in the Pacific Press newspaper clippings, subject “zoning”. Some clippings did not specify the newspaper, but the Vancouver Sun or Province are safe bets.